Thread Rating:
  • 13 Vote(s) - 2.15 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Fully v Semi
#1
Not looking for recommendations or the difference between fully synthetic and part synthetic (we don't need to go into dynamic or kinematic viscosity or Newtonian fluid density), just an answer to the following.
I was under the impression (I used to work in the retail/commercial oil industry) that if an engine has been using fully synthetic oil, then under no circumstances should part synthetic be used. Damage could/would result.
A quick browse on http://www.castrol.com recommends Castrol Edge 5w-40 Fully Synthetic. A correct choice. But under the mid-range choice (Edge is the premium) they recommend Castrol Magnatec 10w-40 Part Synthetic.
What do Citroen themselves recommend?
I could be wrong, technologies may have changed in the 10yrs since leaving the industry.
Reply
#2
(22-08-2012, 11:47 AM)j90xxx Wrote:  ... that if an engine has been using fully synthetic oil, then under no circumstances should part synthetic be used. Damage could/would result.

I can't/don't believe that this is true.

How would you know when buying a secondhand car what oil has been used in it, particularly if it had had a couple of owners.
How much is the fish?
Reply
#3
(22-08-2012, 11:59 AM)knobblywobbly Wrote:  
(22-08-2012, 11:47 AM)j90xxx Wrote:  ... that if an engine has been using fully synthetic oil, then under no circumstances should part synthetic be used. Damage could/would result.

I can't/don't believe that this is true.

How would you know when buying a secondhand car what oil has been used in it, particularly if it had had a couple of owners.

I too have heard this said in the past, but no idea if it's true, or just a clever marketing idea
Reply
#4
Just to throw a spanner in the works aint it recommended to use 5/30 semi synthetic oil in the hdi engines now?
Are we there yet????? Huh
Ex 1.6hdi van now 3 seater 1.4 multispace
Reply
#5
(22-08-2012, 12:36 PM)Coco Wrote:  ..... or just a clever marketing idea

Probably. A bit like saying you can't use car oils in a motorbike with a wet clutch because your clutch will slip, and pointing you to the expensive motorcycle-formulated oils. I've always used car oils in my bikes and never had any clutch slip.
How much is the fish?
Reply
#6
Their recommended oil, the Total Quartz etc. is just listed as a "synthetic based" oil in the lit. I can find. Can't really tell from that if it's fully synthetic or semi.
2010 Berlingo Multispace HDi 110 with FAP.  Persamos green.

Reply
#7
Ok.
In a nutshell (sort of...)
Citroen dealer.
Total Quartz 7000 10w/40 fully synthetic. (see * below)
Total website.
Total Ineo ECS 5w/30 fully synthetic.
Halfords website.
Mobil 1 0w/40 fully synthetic. (see ** below)
Shell website.
Shell Helix Ultra 5w/40 fully synthetic.

So 4 different grades of oil from 3 different manufacturers!

*Citroen dealer said that Quartz 7000 was fully synthetic, but reading on the Total website it is 'synthetic based'. Does that mean 'part synthetic'? Don't think 'based' means 'fully'?
**Halfords also recommend Castrol Magnatec 10w/40 part synthetic for the same vehicle/engine.

Back to my original question, fully or semi?
The Citroen dealer said it should be fully synthetic.
Then quoted me a synthetic 'based' oil...
Am I any wiser?
No!
Reply
#8
Citroen only recommend Total Quartz Ineo ECS 5W30 for their HDi engines.

Other oils, however, are suitable. :-) ( As long as they conform to PAS PEUGEOT & CITROEN B71 2290.)
The Older I get the Better I Was!  Cool
Reply
#9
Not my Citroen dealer!
Reply
#10
I did say 'Citroen'! That doesn't mean one of the witless dealerships who would love to replace your turbocharger
as they're short of work!! LOL!!!
The Older I get the Better I Was!  Cool
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
[-]
Welcome
You have to register before you can post on our site.

Username:
  

Password:
  




[-]
Search
(Advanced Search)

[-]
Latest Threads
Speaker mounting depth
Last Post: Kokain
Yesterday 11:50 PM
» Replies: 3
» Views: 99
Front and rear washers
Last Post: hawaiianblue
Yesterday 11:32 PM
» Replies: 1
» Views: 67
1.6 Hdi 'Missfire' under load (and a clonk)
Last Post: GraemeT
Yesterday 09:06 PM
» Replies: 12
» Views: 1079
Grizz' Prozac for the Soul - Berlingo Multispace
Last Post: Grizz
Yesterday 08:13 PM
» Replies: 524
» Views: 91897
Major investment time.
Last Post: Art b
Yesterday 06:57 PM
» Replies: 7
» Views: 461
Berlingo Exhaust Dilemma
Last Post: hawaiianblue
Yesterday 05:51 PM
» Replies: 4
» Views: 242
FOR SALE: 2015, 65 plate Berlingo Van
Last Post: Tree
Yesterday 05:47 PM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 120
Valves DW8
Last Post: Arbe
Yesterday 05:19 PM
» Replies: 19
» Views: 1521
hi
Last Post: polar
Yesterday 04:42 PM
» Replies: 2
» Views: 176
DW8 cambelt whine after changing it
Last Post: Arbe
Yesterday 12:50 PM
» Replies: 5
» Views: 878

[-]
Recent Visitors
Locations of visitors to this page